She puts me to shame. Io just read the first paragraph to an essay she writing and she’ only 12 but it sounds like something I would’ve written in high school, college even. And this was something she did not want to do. Faced by the challenge of it she wanted to shirk it. To let it go, to let it slide. I told her, this is what I had done, I had become afraid, of being crushed by the possibilities of what I could be. She’s writing an essay for a program that sounds like a cross cultural exchange thing, where a cohort from her school will be a bridge to another in Uniondale. And of course she is afraid, of course she think she can’t.
She told me once while we driving, that she thought my demanding nature instilled a lack of self confidence in her. It still bothers me, but then again, her competitiveness, her yearning to do well, the fact that she also recently said she found middle school a lot easier than she thought it would be, tells me in the end I was right. That I put her on the right path. Yes, she might always be a little shy, might always think she hasn’t done enough, but that has always been the point: a little bit of self doubt goes a long in way in ensuring you are right, that you can always do better.
I listen to David at work, who praises his son but curses his daughter. Rebellious and artistic, his daughter confounds him. I hear him on the phone sometimes with them and the gravitas I have always praised him for attains an edge of harshness that is palpable if not down right smothering. There is only authority in his voice, no compassion. And yet when he speaks of his son, it is almost as if he is baffled by the boy’s temerity, the boy’s lack of spine? That’s not quite right. David is proud of both of them, even his daughter, but it’s almost as if he is worried for his son.
And there we were, Io and I, brain-storming, which she didn’t want to do, “We don’t brain-storm in middle school daddy.” And suddenly, while I was ranting about how privilege we were, how despite her privilege being born a woman gave her a disadvantage, the next thing I knew she was writing, lost in the keyboard. I shut up then, I recognized it. She found the voice of the piece she wanted to write. She found something interesting in that voice and was having a conversation with it. Who was I to interrupt?
